澳洲增CGT 聪明人跑掉 新西兰CGT为零 聪明人都往澳洲跑

yang195508

领英网上某投资商的评论：

xq052b

因为纽村直接用个人税率啊，那个简直了

Amy_XY

同意楼上
故事要看全，否则容易暴露智商

yang195508

自以为“智商高” 的不妨参考一下网上AI对类似本帖的问题回答：
“why australia raising cgt will scare away smart people while new zealand has zero cgt but smart new zealanders keep moving to australia？”



Australia’s overhaul of capital gains tax (CGT)—which transitions long-term investors to an inflation indexation model with a minimum 30% tax floor and eliminates the previous 50% discount—threatens to trigger a "brain drain" of entrepreneurs and founders who fear capital flight and higher tax burdens. In contrast, New Zealand has no broad capital gains tax, yet smart New Zealanders continue to migrate to Australia in droves for one primary reason: vastly higher salaries and deeper, more lucrative career markets.The migration trends and differing tax policies hinge on several key factors:Why Australia's CGT Changes Scare InvestorsHigher Effective Rates: Under the new system, long-term capital gains can be subject to an effective tax rate of up to 47%, which is only marginally offset by inflation adjustments. Start-up founders and fund managers argue this stifles investment and punishes risk-taking.Perceived Hostility to Wealth Creation: By overhauling long-standing structures like the 50% CGT discount, entrepreneurial classes feel Australia is becoming less competitive globally.Trans-Tasman Poaching: The New Zealand government has actively courted Australian businesses and investors by highlighting its stable, zero-CGT environment and portraying Australian tax reforms as a "wrecking ball" to growth.Why Smart Kiwis Still Move to AustraliaDespite New Zealand's lack of a CGT, the allure of crossing the Tasman Sea for Kiwis remains immensely strong:Structural Wage Discrepancy: Australia generally offers significantly higher wages and salaries across almost all professional and skilled sectors compared to New Zealand.Broader Career Opportunities: As a much larger economy, Australia offers deeper pools of capital, larger corporate headquarters, and specialized industries that simply do not exist at scale in New Zealand.Free Movement: Under the Trans-Tasman Travel Arrangement, citizens of both countries can freely move and work across the ditch, allowing Kiwis to chase higher living standards with minimal bureaucratic friction.The Tax RealityWhile New Zealand markets itself as a tax haven with no broad capital gains or inheritance taxes, tax specialists frequently advise that an individual’s wealth is built primarily through their income. Because Australia offers substantially higher earning potential, smart New Zealanders find that the extra income far outweighs the burden of capital gains taxes incurred later in life.

liuyang327

yang195508 发表于 2026-6-7 20:07
自以为“智商高” 的不妨参考一下网上AI对类似本帖的问题回答：
“why australia raising cgt will scare a ...

我没看明白，你发的那段话里不是说聪明的新西兰人都往澳洲跑么。和你的主题正好相反啊。

yang195508

liuyang327 发表于 2026-6-7 21:48
我没看明白，你发的那段话里不是说聪明的新西兰人都往澳洲跑么。和你的主题正好相反啊。 ...

这AI 就是在分析 “为什么新西兰CGT为零而其聪明人仍然往CGT甚多的澳洲跑“啊，咋跟我主题相反了？ 我说的“高智商”是指前面回帖自称智商高的主儿。

Cool7

简单，澳洲要走的是Startup founder， New Zealand要来澳洲的是打工仔，来拿澳洲比NZ高的薪水。完全不冲突。
故意混淆视听

philguo

无论如何打气，澳洲房地产滑向崩溃边缘是不可避免的。即使没有税改，也会被经济下滑所触发。这次应该回调35-40%才能回到合理估值区间。

amyo(∩_∩)o

新西兰房价下跌，哪有cgt，只有captial loss。澳洲这个cgt政策很可能也造成房价下跌，也收不到钱。

还不如不改，保持房价稳定还能收到的钱，现在是双输，政府收不到钱，投资者也赚不到钱

zhengtao

一句话，聪明人不等于有钱人。